Chipotle Mayonnaise Recipe

Chipotle Mayonnaise homemade quickly and easily – Pikantista! Perfect for potato wedges, fries, and burgers. As a Pikantista, you know that the smoky kick of a good chili sauce takes everything to a new level.

Times at a Glance

Preparation Cooking Duration
5 Minutes 10 Minutes 15 Minutes

Chipotle Mayonnaise Ingredients

Pikantistas are chili lovers and gourmets – just like you. And you certainly know this: The best sauces are homemade. Here are all the ingredients you need:

  • 2 egg yolks
  • 2 tbsp Salsa de Chipotle Sauce
  • 1 tsp mustard
  • 1 pinch of salt
  • 200 ml sunflower oil

Preparation

It's that simple – you can do it in under 15 minutes:

Step 1 – Mix Ingredients

Place the egg yolks in a bowl. Add the Chipotle Chili Sauce, mustard, and salt, and mix well.

Step 2 – Stir in Oil

Gradually add the sunflower oil drop by drop while stirring evenly. Make sure all ingredients combine. Adding the oil with continuous whisking must be done slowly and patiently – that is the secret to perfect mayonnaise.

Recipe Additions & Tips

Chill the Chipotle mayonnaise in the refrigerator before serving. It will become even creamier and firmer there – and the flavor will develop perfectly.

Instead of two medium-sized egg yolks, you can also use one large egg yolk. A neutral oil like rapeseed or sunflower oil is best suited as cooking oil. Olive oil has a strong flavor of its own and is therefore less ideal for mayonnaise.

The Chipotle Chili Sauce used must contain acid in the form of vinegar or lemon for success. This recipe works excellently with Mexican Smoker and Old Texas Chipotle Hot Sauces. For other sauces, simply try it out – that's the Pikantista way!

The spiciness of the chili sauces distributes itself in the oil and is only lightly present. The smoky flavor and seasoning of the sauce still come through beautifully – that's what makes this mayonnaise so special.

It is important to slowly combine the oil with the other ingredients. The egg yolk acts as an emulsifier, combining the liquid of the sauce with the oil. For this to work, add the oil only in small amounts with constant stirring. No stress – step by step.

After years of projects like Pika Pika and Chili Mafia, as well as shops like chili-saucen.com and chili-plants.com, we have learned a lot about chili cuisine – we are true Pikantistas, and this recipe is one of our favorites.

Nutritional Values

Average nutritional values (per 100g)
Energy 754 kcal / 3103 kJ

FAQ – Frequently Asked Questions about Chipotle Mayonnaise

Which Chipotle sauce is best for this recipe?

You can basically use any Chipotle chili sauce that contains acid – i.e., vinegar or lemon in the ingredient list. Mexican Smoker and Old Texas Chipotle Hot Sauces have proven particularly good. Pikantista! Simply try them out and see which one you like best.

Why isn't my mayonnaise getting firm?

This usually happens when the oil is added too quickly. The egg yolk, as an emulsifier, needs time to combine the oil with the liquid. Therefore, add the sunflower oil really only drop by drop with constant whisking – patience pays off here.

Can I also make Chipotle mayonnaise with olive oil?

Olive oil has a very distinct flavor of its own, which can overpower the delicate smoky note of the Chipotle chili sauce. Neutral oils like sunflower or rapeseed oil are better suited. This way, the smoky flavor and seasoning of the sauce come through much better.

How long does homemade Chipotle mayonnaise last?

Since this recipe contains raw egg yolks, you should store the Chipotle mayonnaise in the refrigerator and consume it within 2–3 days. In the refrigerator, it also becomes creamier and firmer – a nice side effect.

What can I use Chipotle mayonnaise for?

As a Pikantista, you know that good Chipotle mayonnaise is versatile. It goes perfectly with potato wedges, french fries, burgers, wraps, grilled meat, or as a dip for vegetable sticks. In short: it makes almost everything better!


About the Author

Fabian aka Pikantista

After over 10 years in the European chili scene – from Pika Pika to Chili Mafia and projects like chili-saucen.com and chili-plants.com – the Pikantista shares his knowledge about chili cuisine, hot sauces, and smoky-spicy recipes. Everything tested, everything experienced.

Back to blog